{"id":"W4412001528","doi":"10.5194/egusphere-2025-921-rc1","title":"egusphere-2025-921 introduces an interesting new method, but could do better at explaining it and its novelty","year":2025,"lang":"en","type":"peer-review","venue":"","topic":"Geophysics and Gravity Measurements","field":"Earth and Planetary Sciences","cited_by":0,"is_retracted":false,"has_abstract":true,"ca_institutions":"","funders":"","keywords":"Novelty; Computer science; Computational biology; Biology; Psychology","routes":{"ca_aff":false,"ca_fund":false,"ca_venue":false,"about_ca":true,"invisible_to_affiliation_only":true},"retraction":null,"screen":null,"direct_labels":[],"prediction":{"model_version":"metacan-v3-hybrid-931329e0061c","candidate_categories":[],"consensus_categories":[],"category_scores_codex":[0.001903768,0.0008356582,0.0004627946,0.001739983,0.0004697904,0.002921667,0.001471808,0.001287694,0.04363402],"category_scores_gemma":[0.00366789,0.0002189432,0.0007157319,0.002009621,0.0003984897,0.002510382,0.001288073,0.001411261,0.01521956],"about_ca_system_candidate":false,"about_ca_system_consensus":false,"about_ca_system_score_codex":0.0007926901,"about_ca_system_score_gemma":0.001716874,"about_ca_topic_candidate":false,"about_ca_topic_consensus":false,"about_ca_topic_score_codex":0.01956233,"about_ca_topic_score_gemma":0.02398781,"domain_scores_codex":[0.9996181,0.0000906588,0.00002367007,0.0000861013,0.0001424313,0.00003900466],"domain_scores_gemma":[0.9990671,0.0001488113,0.00005858007,0.0002923297,0.0003454321,0.00008775655],"domain_codex":null,"domain_gemma":null,"domain_candidate":null,"domain_consensus":null,"study_design_codex":"not_applicable","study_design_gemma":"not_applicable","study_design_scores_codex":[0.0003141765,0.0001438378,0.008677141,0.0004372208,0.0001886031,0.0001496505,0.0001088755,0.02928928,0.002371496,0.09520329,0.5825394,0.280577],"study_design_scores_gemma":[0.00009633745,0.00003951039,0.003246747,0.0001867515,0.00003412234,0.00006704881,0.00007559659,0.05391039,0.003014467,0.03228955,0.9069663,0.00007313033],"study_design_candidate":"not_applicable","study_design_consensus":"not_applicable","genre_codex":"methods","genre_gemma":"commentary","genre_scores_codex":[0.01751457,0.002793286,0.4375315,0.02193467,0.01464486,0.0005988191,0.1520898,0.04447742,0.3084151],"genre_scores_gemma":[0.2248537,0.002343451,0.4339393,0.006254616,0.003125957,0.001437053,0.135015,0.03055833,0.1624725],"genre_candidate":"commentary","genre_consensus":null,"teacher_disagreement_score":0.04363402,"threshold_uncertainty_score":0.1459703,"prediction_status":"machine_predicted_unvalidated"},"machine_scores":{"provisional":true,"baseline":true,"maturity_gate_passed":false,"score_opus":0.09494747659993762,"score_gpt":0.3388025833524169,"score_spread":0.2438551067524793,"validation_status":"score_only:v0-immature-baseline","note":"Baseline scores from an immature model (maturity gate not passed). Scores rank; they never assert a category."}}