A New Response to Youth Crime edited by D.J.Smith (Ed.). Abingdon: Routledge (2010) 424pp. £27.50pb IBSN 978‐1‐84392‐754‐9

The youth justice system has been subjected to a series of wide-ranging reforms over recent years, but researchers and other commentators have been critical of these changes for failing to provide effective responses to crime and anti-social behaviour. In response to such criticisms, and with concerns over the high costs of public spending on youth justice, an Independent Commission on Youth Crime and Antisocial Behaviour was set up to critically review the youth justice system. Its purpose was to provide a blueprint for an effective, humane and sustainable approach to youth crime and anti-social behaviour that is based on clear principles and sound evidence. The findings were published in the Commission's 2010 report, Time for a Fresh Start. David Smith is a member of the Commission and in this edited book he brings together contributions from leading experts to provide ‘a framework of evidence and analysis’ in order to support the Commission's work. The book contains twelve considered chapters which present its ‘blueprint for reform’. In the first chapter, Smith sets out ‘the need for a fresh start’ and in the next he explores ‘changing patterns of youth’. The key themes explored in the subsequent chapters include the causes and responses to youth crime and anti-social behaviour (Rutter, Graham and Pople), preventing youth crime (Hawkins, Welsh and Utting), families and parenting (Maughan and Gardner), models of youth justice (McAra), youth justice reform in Canada (Bala, Carrington and Roberts), and ‘public opinion, politics and the response to youth crime’ (Jones). In the concluding chapter, Smith summarises some of the main failures of the current system and sets out nine main recommendations for reform, which are said to reflect key issues arising out of this collection of essays. These include reducing the number of cases brought to court as well as the number of young people taken into custody, increasing the use of restorative conferences and requiring resources to be targeted more towards prevention. While this nine-point plan for reform is to be welcomed, it does not provide the radical approach as suggested in the book's title, A New Response to Youth Crime. However, the apparent conservatism of the main recommendations is likely to be influenced by the book's relationship with the Independent Commission. In particular, with the effective politicisation of youth crime over recent years, the editor will be aware that bringing about change will not be easy. Rather than set out a radical blueprint for reform, therefore, Smith's final chapter can be seen as an appeal to policy makers, with a section on ‘costs and benefits’ helping to present a persuasive argument for the need to bring about change. Nevertheless, this collection of essays does provide evidence and analysis which can help to inform change. McAra's chapter is particularly illuminating, as she grapples with some of the complexities involved when examining different models of youth justice. From my own experience of conducting research into an adversarial system of justice, which includes observing children both in police stations and at court, I would argue that the need for alternative models based on welfare and restorative justice principles are long overdue.

Récupéré en direct depuis OpenAlex et désinversé. Les résumés ne sont pas conservés dans cette base de données : les index inversés représentent 8,6 Go des 9,3 Go de texte de la base, et le serveur dispose de 13 Go libres.