Do We Need to Care About Professionals in Order to Mobilize Them? A Data Reanalysis
Notice bibliographique
Résumé
According to Julien (1991), there seems to be a feeling of demobilization among the professionals in Quebec’s public service. This feeling is caused, in part, by inappropriate management styles. For instance, professionals tend to express more discontent when their superiors adopt an abdicant management style. As a conclusion, Julien asserts that professionals prefer a directing style to an abdicant style of management. Since these results were not in line with theories (clash of culture, mobilization as a form of behavioural organizational commitment, empowerment), data were reanalyzed in order to shed light on this issue. The typology of management style proposed by Julien was constructed by using two empirical dimensions (concern for the accomplishment of work and concern for employee well being), and one unmeasured dimension (concern for power). By dividing each empirical dimension into three levels (low, medium high), Julien proposed nine different management styles. Given that arbitrary cut-off points were used for dividing empirical dimensions, it is possible that some of the nine styles do not exist empirically. Furthermore, it is possible that using the unmeasured dimension of power in data analysis may affect data results. This provided the rationale for data reanalysis.As explained by Julien (1991: 614), the data for this study were collected in November and December 1987 and in January 1988. A questionnaire was sent to a probability sample of 4,502 professionals, divided in three areas of employment (Greater Quebec City, Greater Montreal and the remaining areas), and in 24 government departments and 48 agencies. This sample was picked at systematic random among some 13,000 professionals, whether or not they are members of a union, and who are under Quebec’s law on public service. No reminder was sent, and the overall reply rate reached 50,8%. The 2,289 professionals who took part in the research are proportionally representative of all the employees of that category, according to details such as sex, age, number of years in service, employment area, size of organization.Julien’s data were subsequently reanalyzed with traditional statistical techniques (such as exploratory factor analysis and cluster analysis) and with modern statistical methods (such as confirmatory factor analysis and structural equations). Cluster analysis showed that only five management styles emerged (instead of the nine identified by Julien). Among the five management styles, the abdicant style was merged with the directing style. Furthermore, data analysis showed that professionals were more dissatisfied with an abdicant/directing style than with any other management style.Since the issue of mobilization was at stake, a model based on Julien’s conceptual framework was tested with structural equations. This model related (1) the two measured management style dimensions (concern for the accomplishment of the work and concern for well being) to (2) professionals’ mobilization through (3) professionals’ satisfaction with management style. Data results showed that professionals’ mobilization was indirectly influenced by the concern expressed by their superiors for employee well being (interest for participation) through professionals’ satisfaction with the human side of superiors’ management style. In other words, satisfaction with management style was more influenced by the concern for employee well being than by the concern for the accomplishment of work (supervision). Furthermore, Julien’s conclusions about professionals’ desire to be controlled need to be interpreted cautiously since the dimension of power was not measured. As a rule, adopting a participative management style and caring for professionals are useful for mobilizing them.
Récupéré en direct depuis OpenAlex et désinversé. Les résumés ne sont pas conservés dans cette base de données : les index inversés représentent 8,6 Go des 9,3 Go de texte de la base, et le serveur dispose de 13 Go libres.
Comment cette classification a été obtenuedéplier
Prédiction machine sur la base complète
Imitation des enseignantsNi prévalence calibrée, ni vérité terrain. Validation humaine à venir. Le volet Gemma est une étiquette directe du modèle pour chaque travail de la base, lue sur la notice réduite au titre. Le volet Codex est un classifieur appris des 10 348 étiquettes directes de Codex et calibré sur les taux pondérés de l'échantillon; les champs sans appui suffisant ne portent aucun appel Codex. Le mode candidate est l'union des deux volets; le consensus est leur intersection. Ces sorties portent le statut machine_predicted_unvalidated et ne sont pas des étiquettes humaines.
Scores du classifieur distillé par catégorie (deux têtes)
| Catégorie | Codex | Gemma |
|---|---|---|
| Métarecherche | 0,009 | 0,035 |
| Méta-épidémiologie (sens strict) | 0,001 | 0,001 |
| Méta-épidémiologie (sens large) | 0,001 | 0,001 |
| Bibliométrie | 0,013 | 0,013 |
| Études des sciences et des technologies | 0,002 | 0,002 |
| Communication savante | 0,003 | 0,003 |
| Science ouverte | 0,002 | 0,002 |
| Intégrité de la recherche | 0,001 | 0,002 |
| Charge utile insuffisante (le modèle a refusé de juger) | 0,009 | 0,003 |
Scores machine (provisoires)
Les deux têtes enseignantes du modèle étudiant, lues sur ce travail. Un score ordonne la base pour la relecture; il n'affirme jamais une catégorie, et le statut de validation accompagne chaque rangée tel quel.
Scores de référence d'un modèle non mature (critères de maturité non atteints, 7 itérations). Un score ordonne; il n'affirme jamais une catégorie.
score_only:v0-immature-baseline · tel quel depuis la passe de notation : score_only signifie que le nombre peut ordonner les travaux, et qu'aucune étiquette de catégorie n'en découleClassification
machine, non validéePrédiction automatique; un appel candidat d’une seule source (Gemma direct ou Codex distillé), pas un consensus.
Le détail, modèle par modèle et score par score, se trouve en fin de page sous « Comment cette classification a été obtenue ».