MétaCan
Menu
← Retour à la cohorte
Enregistrement W301793977

Under the Shadow of the Swastika: Moral Dilemmas of Resistance and Collaboration in Hitler's Europe

2001· article· en· W301793977 sur OpenAlexaboutno aff
George Manolovich

Notice bibliographique

RevueShofar · 2001
Typearticle
Langueen
DomaineSocial Sciences
ThématiqueItalian Fascism and Post-war Society
Établissements canadiensnon disponible
Organismes subventionnairesnon disponible
Mots-clésNazismThe HolocaustNazi concentration campsLawWorld War IINazi GermanyDissentDeportationShadow (psychology)Political scienceResistance (ecology)GermanIdeologySociologyReligious studiesPoliticsHistoryPhilosophyPsychoanalysisPsychologyImmigration
DOInon disponible

Résumé

récupéré en direct d'OpenAlex

Reviewed by: Under the Shadow of the Swastika: The Moral Dilemmas of Resistance and Collaboration in Hitler’s Europe George M. Kren Under the Shadow of the Swastika: The Moral Dilemmas of Resistance and Collaboration in Hitler’s Europe, by Rab Bennett. New York: New York University Press, 1999. 318 pp. Studs Terkel characterized World War II as “the good war.” It is a view that still commands assent. Arthur Koestler spoke of World War II as a fight between the gray and the black. The nature of Nazi Germany with its radical violation of what have come to be regarded as civilized values was such that it continues to be viewed as evil that had to be destroyed. Bennett cites Jean Amery’s statement that “The Swastika . . . became the universal symbol of what is humanly and historically intolerable.” Even now few would dissent from this view. Nazi Germany occupied much of Europe. Occupation policies were almost always brutal—mass executions, torture, deportations, forced labor all were part of Hitler’s “New Order.” In countries occupied by Germany some individuals became collaborators. [End Page 151] Motives for collaboration varied. Some acted out of self-interest. Others, such as Vidkun Quisling in Norway, did so because they believed in and supported Nazi ideology. Many saw collaboration as the lesser evil compared to its alternatives. In France Marshal Pétain and Pierre Laval believed that reaching an understanding with the Nazis would moderate excesses, that their collaboration with them would save lives. Yet German demands increased and “moral contamination became unavoidable”(p. 56) And Vichy and Nazi Germany shared some views, such as anti-Semitism. Laval coordinated Jewish deportations, and encouraged the deportation of children under 16. Civil servants in occupied countries usually stayed on their jobs, as did the police forces who, usually willingly, carried out German demands. Resistance movements against the German occupation and against collaborators arose as German brutalities increased and as the fortunes of war turned against Germany. Bennett notes the development of a romantic myth of the resistance after the war. Popularized in novels, radio, films and TV—I recall a song by Leonard Cohen glorifying the partisan from the 1960s—the image of the resistance fighter as heroic and morally pure still is widely held. The mass bombing of cities—there is now near universal agreement that the bombing of Dresden was “wrong”—the targeting of civilians and other acts have been questioned, but resistance movements have not received any critical examination. Under the Shadow of the Swastika holds that while we must recognize “the enormous physical and moral courage that it required to engage in underground warfare” (p. 27), moral issues about resistance activities need to be examined. For example, the use of torture by members of the resistance, which Bennett documents in some detail, has not been mentioned in studies about the resistance movement. The Germans exacted heavy vengeance for the killing or wounding of German soldiers. Depending on time and place, 100 or more hostages might be shot as punishment for the killing of one German soldier. In Kiev as reprisal for a bombing, 1250 people were executed. In Athens in 1942, 300 Greeks were executed in reprisal for the death of General Krech. Max Weber made a distinction between ethics of conviction and ethics of responsibility. By the latter he meant that an action must be judged on its probable consequences. Bennett suggests that members of the resistance had an obligation to take the certainty of German reprisals into account: “The German practice . . . raised the painful question of whether it was right for resisters to endanger the lives of large numbers of innocent people by actions which would bring down extensive reprisals . . . . Burdened with this terrible guilt—the blood of the innocents— resistors constantly had to balance the benefits of paramilitary action against the certainty of savage retribution” (pp. 115–116). Bennett discusses the still controversial issue of Jewish collaboration and resistance. He examines Hannah Arendt’s controversial thesis that the members of the Jewish councils, the Judenrat, actively collaborated with the Nazis, and significantly [End Page 152] contributed to Nazi success in carrying out the “final solution.” His view is that...

Récupéré en direct depuis OpenAlex et désinversé. Les résumés ne sont pas conservés dans cette base de données : les index inversés représentent 8,6 Go des 9,3 Go de texte de la base, et le serveur dispose de 13 Go libres.

Comment cette classification a été obtenuedéplier

Prédiction machine sur la base complète

Imitation des enseignants

Ni prévalence calibrée, ni vérité terrain. Validation humaine à venir. Le volet Gemma est une étiquette directe du modèle pour chaque travail de la base, lue sur la notice réduite au titre. Le volet Codex est un classifieur appris des 10 348 étiquettes directes de Codex et calibré sur les taux pondérés de l'échantillon; les champs sans appui suffisant ne portent aucun appel Codex. Le mode candidate est l'union des deux volets; le consensus est leur intersection. Ces sorties portent le statut machine_predicted_unvalidated et ne sont pas des étiquettes humaines.

score de la tête « metaresearch » (Codex)0,023
score de la tête « metaresearch » (Gemma)0,015
Version: metacan-v3-hybrid-931329e0061cStatut de validation: machine_predicted_unvalidated
Catégories candidatesaucune
Catégories consensuellesaucune
DomaineSignal candidat: aucune · Signal consensuel: aucune
Devis d'étudeSignal candidat: Qualitatif · Signal consensuel: aucune
GenreSignal candidat: Empirique · Signal consensuel: Empirique
Score de désaccord entre enseignants0,044
Score d'incertitude au seuil0,120

Scores du classifieur distillé par catégorie (deux têtes)

CatégorieCodexGemma
Métarecherche0,0230,015
Méta-épidémiologie (sens strict)0,0010,001
Méta-épidémiologie (sens large)0,0010,001
Bibliométrie0,0020,002
Études des sciences et des technologies0,0440,073
Communication savante0,0300,013
Science ouverte0,0020,019
Intégrité de la recherche0,0160,011
Charge utile insuffisante (le modèle a refusé de juger)0,0030,000

Scores machine (provisoires)

Les deux têtes enseignantes du modèle étudiant, lues sur ce travail. Un score ordonne la base pour la relecture; il n'affirme jamais une catégorie, et le statut de validation accompagne chaque rangée tel quel.

Scores de référence d'un modèle non mature (critères de maturité non atteints, 7 itérations). Un score ordonne; il n'affirme jamais une catégorie.

Tête enseignante Opus0,019
Tête enseignante GPT0,274
Écart entre enseignants0,256 · la distance entre les deux têtes enseignantes sur ce seul travail
Statut de validationscore_only:v0-immature-baseline · tel quel depuis la passe de notation : score_only signifie que le nombre peut ordonner les travaux, et qu'aucune étiquette de catégorie n'en découle

Classification

machine, non validée

Prédiction automatique; un appel candidat d’une seule source (Gemma direct ou Codex distillé), pas un consensus.

Les modèles n’ont appliqué aucune catégorie : rien dans la taxonomie ne correspondait à ce travail.
Devis d'étudeQualitatif
Domainenon disponible
GenreEmpirique

Le détail, modèle par modèle et score par score, se trouve en fin de page sous « Comment cette classification a été obtenue ».

En bref

Citations1
Publié2001
Routes d'admission1
Résumé présentoui

Explorer davantage

Même revueShofar→Même sujetItalian Fascism and Post-war Society→Travaux en français237 207→