Online Medical Education: It Is Time to Listen to the Silence

To the Editor: Recently, I have seen greater recognition of the role of silence in medical education, helping reverse the negative connotations traditionally associated with silence. While silence has been interpreted to indicate a lack of knowledge, interest, or competence, it has been increasingly encouraged as an effective pedagogical tool in the classroom and the clinical setting 1: faculty make pauses during their presentations to add dramatic effect, attract students’ attention, and allow students to learn at their own pace. Clinical educators may also incorporate silence into their bedside teaching to help trainees reflect, process, interact, and ask questions. Silence is a complex, multidimensional phenomenon influenced by personality factors and sociocultural ones. For instance, introverted learners might be silent, as they save up their questions for the appropriate time, and nonverbal students tend to concentrate without feeling the urge to express their opinions. Also, there are cultural differences regarding how silence is employed and acknowledged. While silence is avoided in some cultures, it is positively viewed in others, implying respect and openness. Hence, besides the educational benefits, diversity and equality could be promoted if silence was appropriately addressed. Although silence has been discussed in face-to-face teaching, little is known about “online silence.” During the pandemic, everyone has experienced those awkward moments of silence in an online meeting. When there is no answer or comment, particularly in the absence of visible body language, it is difficult to guess whether silence is a sign of agreement, lack of interest, or a way to avoid expressing opinions. Also, whereas taking turns in speaking comes naturally in the spontaneity of free-flowing classroom conversations, taking turns online is sometimes more difficult because speakers have trouble sensing when to give up control of the conversation. Strategies enabling silence as a teaching asset in online education include listening without interrupting, offering purposeful silence, and providing active silent time. 2 Because of the discomfort around silence, teachers may evade situations with a risk of silence. Yet they could help students overcome that discomfort and contribute authentically to discussions by being explicit about silence, clarifying expectations, and maintaining a safe environment. 2 Current scholarship around silence is scarce. I therefore expect a call for further investigation to develop a deeper understanding of the notion of silence in online medical education. In-depth interviews, real-time observations, and analyses of video recordings could afford insight into how silence is perceived and addressed in online medical education and how silence is integrated into such education. Research on the role and influence of silence could equip teachers with more subtle teaching skills and help students be more engaged in learning. The findings of such research could offer practical implications to all who will probably continue teaching and learning via online platforms, even on the far side of the COVID-19 outbreak.

Récupéré en direct depuis OpenAlex et désinversé. Les résumés ne sont pas conservés dans cette base de données : les index inversés représentent 8,6 Go des 9,3 Go de texte de la base, et le serveur dispose de 13 Go libres.