Peer Review #2 of "Higher bee abundance, but not pest abundance, in landscapes with more agriculture on a late-flowering legume crop in tropical smallholder farms (v0.1)"

Background: Landscape composition is known to affect both beneficial insect and pest communities on crop fields.Landscape composition therefore can impact ecosystem (dis)services provided by insects to crops.Though landscape effects on ecosystem service providers have been studied in large-scale agriculture in temperate regions, there is a lack of representation of tropical smallholder agriculture within this field of study, especially in sub-Sahara Africa.Legume crops can provide important food security and soil improvement benefits to vulnerable agriculturalists.However, legumes are dependent on pollinating insects, particularly bees (Hymenoptera: Apiformes) for production and are vulnerable to pests.We selected 10 pigeon pea (Fabacae: Cajunus cajan (L.)) fields in Malawi with varying proportions of semi-natural habitat and agricultural area within a 1km radius to study: (1) how the proportion of seminatural habitat and agricultural area affects the abundance and richness of bees and abundance of florivorous blister beetles (Coleoptera: Melloidae), (2) if the proportion of flowers damaged and fruit set difference between open and bagged flowers are correlated with the proportion of semi-natural habitat or agricultural area and (3) if pigeon pea fruit set difference between open and bagged flowers in these landscapes was constrained by pest damage or improved by bee visitation.Methods: We performed three, ten-minute, 15 meters, transects per field to assess blister beetle abundance and bee abundance and richness.Bees were captured and identified to (morpho)species.We assessed the proportion of flowers damaged by beetles during the flowering period.We performed a pollinator and pest exclusion experiment on 15 plants per field to assess whether fruit set was pollinator limited or constrained by pests.Results: In our study, bee abundance was higher in areas with proportionally more agricultural area surrounding the fields.This effect was mostly driven by an increase in honeybees.Bee richness and beetle abundances were not affected by landscape characteristics, nor was flower damage or fruit set difference between bagged and open flowers.We did not observe a positive effect of bee density or richness, nor a negative effect of florivory, on fruit set difference.Discussion: In our study area, pigeon pea flowers relatively late -well into the dry season.This could explain why we observe higher densities of bees in areas dominated by agriculture rather than in areas with more semi-natural habitat where resources for bees during this time of the year are scarce.Therefore, late flowering legumes may be an important food resource for bees during a period of scarcity in the seasonal tropics.The differences in patterns between our study and those conducted in temperate

Récupéré en direct depuis OpenAlex et désinversé. Les résumés ne sont pas conservés dans cette base de données : les index inversés représentent 8,6 Go des 9,3 Go de texte de la base, et le serveur dispose de 13 Go libres.