The International Olympic Committee (IOC) Consensus Statement on Periodic Health Evaluation of Elite Athletes: March 2009
Bibliographic record
Abstract
The Olympic Games is the largest sport event in the world. In Beijing, 10500 athletes competed, selected from a large group of elite athletes in 204 countries. Sports participation on the elite level, aside from winning medals, fame and other rewards, is also important from a health perspective. There is no longer any doubt that regular physical activity reduces the risk of premature mortality in general, and of coronary heart disease, hypertension, colon cancer, obesity, and diabetes mellitus in particular. The question is whether the health benefits of sports participation outweigh the risk of injury and long-term disability, especially in high-level athletes. Sarna et al (2000) have studied the incidence of chronic disease and life expectancy of former male world-class athletes from Finland in endurance sports, power sports and team sports. The overall life expectancy was longer in the high-level athlete compared to a reference group (75.6 versus 69.9 years). The same group also showed that the rate of hospitalization later in life was lower for endurance sports and power sports compared to the reference group (Kujala 1996). This resulted from a lower rate of hospital care for heart disease, respiratory disease and cancer. However, the athletes were more likely to have been hospitalized for musculoskeletal disorders. Thus, the evidence suggests that although there is a general health benefit from sports participation, injuries represent a significant side effect.One priority of the International Olympic Committee (IOC) is to protect the health of the athlete. During recent years, prevention of injuries and illnesses has been high on the IOC agenda. During the Athens Games an injury surveillance system was applied for all team sports (Junge et al 2006). During the Beijing Games, the IOC ran, for the first time, an injury surveillance system covering all the athletes, showing a 10% incidence of injuries (Junge et al 2008). In Vancouver and London the surveillance system will include disease conditions as well. The surveillance studies are prerequisites for providing evidence for health development in sports as well as for developing prevention programs. Another method to decrease injuries and diseases in the elite athlete is to perform a pre-participation examination (PPE) or periodic health evaluation (PHE) of all elite athletes (Junge at al 2009). PHE in various forms have been available for many years, but a recent analysis (Wingfield et al 2004) has questioned the efficacy of PHEs in detecting serious problems in the elite athlete.In March 2009, the IOC assembled an expert group to discuss the current state of health evaluations for athletes, aiming to provide recommendations for a practical PHE for the elite athlete, as well as to outline the need for further research. The task of the group was to review the benefits as well as potential negative effects of PHE at the elite sport level. The group did not take any position as to whether PHE should be recommended as compulsory for participation in sport. That is for the relevant sports authorities to decide.The PHE can serve many purposes. It includes a comprehensive assessment of the athlete's current health status and risk of future injury or disease and, typically, is the entry point for medical care of the athlete. The PHE also serves as a tool for continuous health monitoring in athletes. Recent advances in this field relate to: (i) data on sudden cardiac death and other noncardiac medical problems, and the detection of risk factors and groups; (ii) a consensus conference on concussion; (iii) data on eating disorders and (iv) data on risk factors for musculoskeletal injuries. This paper addresses each of these advances in more detail after a discussion on the purpose of a PHE and the evidence we have supporting the different components of the PHE.In a narrow sense, the main purpose of the PHE is to screen for injuries or medical conditions that may place an athlete at risk for safe participation. Athletes may be affected by conditions that do not have overt symptoms and that can only be detected by periodic health evaluations. One example is cardiovascular abnormalities, such as hypertrophic cardiomyopathy, arrythmogenic right ventricular cardiomyopathy or congenital coronary arteries anomalies. These are typically silent until a potentially fatal arrhythmia occurs, but may in some cases be detected through a careful cardiovascular examination.Screening is a strategy used in a population to detect a disease in individuals without signs or symptoms of that disease. The intention is to identify pathologic conditions early, thus enabling earlier intervention and management in the hope of reducing future morbidity and mortality. Although screening may lead to an earlier diagnosis, not all screening programs have been shown to benefit the person being screened.To ensure that screening programs confer the intended benefit, the World Health Organisation published what have become known as the Wilson-Jungner criteria for appraising a screening programme (Wilson & Jungner 1968). The main criteria are that the condition being screened for is an important health problem (depends not just on how serious the condition is, but also how common it is), that there is a detectable early stage, that treatment at an early stage is of more benefit than at a later stage and that a suitable test is available to detect disease in the early stage.From a public health perspective, there is insufficient evidence to date to mandate any specific screening tests for elite athletes apart from those recommended for the general population. This is mainly the consequence of the low risk of serious conditions in this population. An important limitation is also the lack of suitable screening tests; such tests must be reliable (repeatable, good inter-observer agreement), sensitive (detects all those with increased risk), specific (detects only those with increased risk), affordable (ideally cheap, easy to perform, widely available), acceptable to the screening population and subject to quality assurance.However, the PHE may serve other purposes than just screening athletes for future health problems. One obvious goal is to ensure that current health problems are managed appropriately and, ultimately, to determine whether an athlete is medically suitable to engage in a particular sport or event. Even elite athletes with easy access to medical care do not always seek medical attention for injuries or disease, despite having significant symptoms.Some silent conditions are common and, although not severe from a health perspective, may influence sports performance. An example of this is mild iron deficiency, which is common in female athletes. Periodic health evaluations and ongoing monitoring represent an opportunity to diagnose and manage such conditions. They also provide an opportunity to identify conditions that are barriers to performance. An example is astigmatism, which can be detected on a simple test of visual acuity. Another important function of periodic health evaluations is that they allow the athlete an opportunity to establish a relationship with the health personnel who will be involved in providing continuing care.Finally, the PHE also represents an opportunity to for which may the elite athlete at risk for future injury or disease. However, as there is evidence to that it is to future on the there is evidence in some such as injury risk assessment & that future and to the on the sport and the and of the athlete, it may be to include an assessment of specific risk factors in the is important to and the and of the PHE in to protect the and of athletes, and other In the of and a the need to be many the PHE is used to medical to in sport and is as a for future in elite sport. However, the evaluation of the athlete's health should be as a ongoing many of the PHE will be common to all elite athletes, it should be to be and sport specific any injury or medical condition is it should be managed in a with the of medical this may to the for further evaluation and It should be that the PHE is also the that or in or should be to determine a to the World is of the PHE should allow for for management of any injuries or medical problems well it is to a PHE the that or other treatment can the athlete to health physical the PHE is the only that many elite athletes will have with medical it should be as an opportunity for other health and is in that to the various of evaluation to the elite of the cardiovascular PHE is to detect potentially cardiovascular disease in elite athletes and management to the risk for sudden cardiac death disease in a participation in and is with an increased risk for sudden cardiac death with an risk for athletes of compared to et al It is to that sport is not the for incidence of It is the of physical in athletes with cardiovascular disease, which can to cardiac The risk of sport participation is different to the disease, and it is in of as hypertrophic cardiomyopathy or right ventricular or congenital coronary arteries et al of the athletes do not symptoms the PHE represents the only strategy to identify athletes with silent cardiac disease, and allow management to the risk of and disease athletes with cardiovascular disease through the PHE is important be by from sports but also treatment by or other Athletes an increased cardiac risk may have a long-term to and management et al evidence the of in reducing mortality in screened athletes et al 2006). This is on the that is in individuals with hypertrophic cardiomyopathy to and right ventricular cardiomyopathy to The can also identify athletes with and such as disease, or and et al and 2008). However, has been to available data on the of in elite athletes to the lack of an of athletes screened with athletes will large athlete athletes, in of the low incidence of long-term to the of athletes at has been that a examination to and physical examination in a in the to identify potentially heart disorders et al and and this strategy has been in et al and the of recommendations et al However, it is not recommended by the and should be on a to of the can be to the criteria by et al the common in athletes first in or right criteria for with athlete's and of and that do not all other common should be further to cardiovascular disease there is no the need for of in the is there a for of other or However, in the of at physical examination or should be in to cardiovascular disease. In is the but other as cardiac or may be In athletes in the of PHE is to detect cardiac and is recommended for elite athletes with increased cardiovascular risk IOC PHE that any athlete with a should be managed to the widely and recommendations and et al The group that of cardiac disease in an athlete represents a question the medical and consequence with particular to the need for from However, there is evidence that athletes with specific cardiovascular from regular and is an strategy for et al et al from participation of athletes with diseases is a there is a need for a common of sports and management of athletes with cardiovascular diseases in the future et al 2008). The main goal should be to the of and to than sports activity in to the specific cardiovascular we that athletes specific in the of and sport with sport should and intended to the and of involved in the of the PHE there are of of the for athlete screening there is evidence to a with evaluation to the of the test in a of provide a group to in screened and the mortality effects of a screening in need to be in other the disease conditions may from those in sport and sport should that current and data the and to in the main of the PHE have been to screen elite athletes for risk for sudden cardiovascular death et al et al musculoskeletal injury and injury of the PHE that on medical conditions have to date been to conditions disease, and and specific medical of the female athlete and sports who perform medical on elite athletes, as well as of the medical team that athletes to the Olympic Games and other sports medical conditions that are and are of a et al it was that of the athletes at the medical at the Olympic Games were for illnesses et al In in the athlete medical the Olympic Games, medical respiratory were more than conditions et al in other of the medical in a team Olympic Games were It is important to that the of medical in these studies was low medical conditions in other than the cardiovascular system are common in elite athletes. These conditions can of in for and after In the of medical conditions in athletes the Olympic Games has been These data that medical other than cardiovascular are common in elite athletes, these conditions have not attention in a of medical conditions can in athletes a of medical and these can be a PHE et al a of these conditions are and can be for sports participation athletes from these conditions is an ongoing and ongoing monitoring and purpose of this is to review the evidence for in the PHE that on medical in the medical physical examination and that be in a PHE to identify significant medical and future for in this is data available on the of assessment for medical conditions in a for the of screening tests to identify medical conditions in a PHE is to expert and However, the of some medical conditions is in the medical physical examination and of of PHE recommendations et al et al et al et al and et al The evidence for screening to identify medical conditions in a will be for an assessment of the system in a PHE is that respiratory symptoms that are of are common in athletes et al 2008). the of a these symptoms can be and the with tests can be used to the of et al 2008). The of in athletes is high and from in sports to in sports et al et al 2008). a respiratory conditions other than that can also to respiratory symptoms in athletes can be et al main for assessment a PHE is on the than of iron in athletes, female athletes et al and et al et al et al 2008). An is to determine the athlete has or and to identify other illnesses such as It is that has been as a tool for as well et al The of a on screening is in compared with male athletes et al for in the PHE to identify in elite athletes is on the that than of conditions has been in elite athletes et al et al et al athletes be to a of at different take place et al and and chronic in morbidity and also et al to disease in a PHE is on a of important it is that and there is evidence of in athletes that to disease et al 2006). is a to participation in sports of the risk of injury and in some cases increased risk of of the to athletes et al and and the PHE an opportunity to whether an athlete has been those that may be with to specific There are a of illnesses that be a PHE and these have been et al and for the and assessment in a PHE is on the high incidence medical that are to this system in elite athletes the common illnesses in the system of athletes are et al et al and respiratory et al et al et al 2006). The for this of conditions in PHE has been for a assessment in the PHE is that disorders are common in athletes participation in sports may athletes to conditions and there is a risk of of conditions sports 2008). to may have to be athletes from some for an assessment of the system in the PHE is not on However, it is known that and disease can be and conditions such as and are screening in athletes is and 2008). Although these conditions may not be they do further evaluation to for an assessment of the system in the PHE is that symptoms are common in athletes endurance sports participation and 2008). of significant disease is important in athletes, those that from symptoms and 2008). conditions are also with athletes to for assessment of conditions in the PHE of athletes is that conditions are common and can include a of different conditions such as and although can in athletes. It has been that the PHE should include screening for the risk factors of in athletes for to determine elite athletes have and disease is that these conditions do in elite of the more common conditions in elite athletes is diabetes mellitus Olympic athletes for the of in the Olympic Games et al and elite athletes with and disease may and they may et al for assessment in the PHE is that visual have been in of athletes a PHE et al and common conditions can also be of medical conditions a PHE include an medical physical examination and selected should that are recommended are and and tests for iron to medical these should be in the PHE to elite athletes for the of medical in sport is as a the by et al in the from to to sport and and for and There is evidence that are in sport IOC and of the consensus group in the recent on in et al and and conference was after the of the of development of The specific evidence and are in detail in the by et al is that a is an important of the and should include specific purpose in such a may identify athletes that a high risk and an opportunity for the to the athlete in to the of in et al discussion and general on the of assessment the PHE in high risk sports. The is to provide a point for future injury a specific for examination in the PHE was not in the consensus of the future in was the assessment no assessment has been et al health evaluation has significant to the of an in health will ensure good function and the of the athlete to at an without being by disease or an by the IOC at recent have the of disease in many The of a a screening and to disease may also identify health and the of health in elite athlete group et al The of the of which is to be in athletes, may be an of of sports which are in et al In may be by which may be of an eating of et al et al and are risk factors for future injury et al The or of may the risk for in sports et al et al et al and may athlete physical examination should include the risk factors for injury that can be for prevention should be to athletes and authorities the benefits in injuries by providing for those in sports and et al and to to or the further studies are to more the health of the athlete population and programs should be and to those sports the influence athlete health et al The IOC group athletes to be with regular injuries are common in sports. injuries are common in sports in which the is high and the risk of is and in team sports there is significant and injuries the large of injuries in sports that with or However, a large of injuries also in sports, in which the same is and high The injury also from sport to each sport has injury This must be the musculoskeletal of the The must be with the common injury with the sport in question and the examination should be on these injury and risk main of the musculoskeletal PHE is to detect current injuries and ensure that these are managed an athlete may have through in the of the is on to and to protect from further The should be used as an opportunity to the athlete to the of the PHE may be the there is to on problems that are than the injury is the risk for injuries. This has been for a of different injury such as and injuries. injury function through or or function through or more in the It that programs to and can injuries. One important of the musculoskeletal PHE is to identify or from the musculoskeletal PHE should be used to identify athletes at risk for However, although a of risk factors have been which an athlete to different the examination to be on the and of the sport in review of risk factors with injuries to the different can be in the IOC on Sports & evidence for a musculoskeletal PHE to detect risk factors for future injury is with a of injury or symptoms function are a group with an increased injury risk that should be for and with specific prevention programs However, in the athlete with no of there is evidence to specific tests more tests to identify athletes at One limitation is that the of such tests is Another is that the of such tests is for the of the musculoskeletal PHE is a of current and musculoskeletal injuries. the can these should in detail for the and injury with the sport in question to ensure that no injuries and symptoms are The examination should on any symptoms or injuries of of and and relevant or more tests may be on and physical studies are to the components of and examination that can be used to identify athletes at and athlete participation in sport has increased with of the athletes at the Beijing Olympic Games being female Olympic Committee 2008). the health benefits of there are medical conditions to the female athlete that may have long-term that can be through early detection and from to the of can lead to disorders and low This is to as the female athlete et al In iron is more common in the female athlete et al 2008). The health and of these conditions can be through early detection and The PHE a opportunity for the team to detect and low low and iron of eating disorders and eating disorders not in the sport population was to be in with in the general population. The in is lower than in and and The sports at are the sports that endurance sports and sports and The of widely on the of sport and is as high as in in to in the general population and The incidence of with et al with athletes in sports and and in athletes than of et al The incidence of is in and and in to in the general population et al the of low in athletes is to than the general population et al more in athletes with and low et al and of the female athlete are well in the and treatment et al the detection of eating disorders and screening the et al et al et al the et al et al and the for et al of the and screening by et that serve as and as negative of eating in PHE et al population of high endurance with low was to on the of in with other The and low are shown in et al and physical examination of the female athlete should each of the female athlete to detect eating disorders and eating should be of and a of should be review may identify affected by low of a analysis the athlete at risk for and iron physical examination should include a The physical signs can be in cases of eating disorders but are likely to be in early of the of examination is recommended in the athlete with or examination should include a for all female athletes and a for those athletes in endurance sports. those athletes at risk for the female athlete on a screening physical examination and of is these athletes, tests include a screen to to from in eating disorders and a analysis to should be the relationship the female athlete and sports participation. the for detecting the is for and for earlier of athletes who benefit from the relationship low as a of iron is important for medical and care with female athletes should be and in the and treatment of the female athlete and iron programs for athletes and on prevention of the female athlete and iron are recommended to decrease the incidence of these health to and to ensure that female athletes the benefits of sport represents an for the of a medical and can for the purpose of and to It can also as a for ongoing and of the and athlete PHE may a the sports and with an in PHE can review and on the and of this PHE components of the PHE the of the PHE and analysis of the and of the the components can be the any such programs to the for and and that they are in with the for the and of Health An of the PHE be in the of the enabling the participation of athletes, medical and from with and An an to data the of any data an which PHE data can be and the ongoing of to the In all cases the and of this health data is of the are to the and or of athlete data the should be was to provide a practical PHE that be used by various and a point for further and in is not we do not The first in such a was to those in These the the the the forms the recommendations the the in the of this The was to these a of that was This was to the for will be to through in the This should be on the of which will through evaluation with data in a of IOC has high-level who are of monitoring in the field of and of the IOC in to the and of These will ensure that athletes and the benefits of these in to and to The IOC will this field and a conference in is recommended that PHEs be and as the to a compulsory PHE must be by the International It must be in with and to should be and used by the medical and to further and In such should be with the of in particular the by the World and the of the Olympic sports Olympic and International are to to provide sport specific and medical evidence as to the and of has been in the of Sports of Sports of International Sports of of and in of and in of Sports
Fetched live from OpenAlex and de-inverted. Abstracts are not stored in this database: the inverted indexes are 8.6 GB of the frame’s 9.3 GB of text, and the host has 13 GB free.
How this classification was reachedexpand
Full frame machine prediction
Teacher imitationNot calibrated prevalence, not ground truth. Human validation pending. The Gemma side is a direct model label for every work in the frame, read from the title-only record. The Codex side is a classifier learned from the 10,348 direct Codex labels and calibrated to design-weighted sample rates; fields without enough sample support carry no Codex call. Candidate is the union of the two sides; consensus is their intersection. These outputs are machine_predicted_unvalidated and are not human labels.
Distilled classifier scores by category (both heads)
| Category | Codex | Gemma |
|---|---|---|
| Metaresearch | 0.053 | 0.056 |
| Meta-epidemiology (narrow) | 0.002 | 0.002 |
| Meta-epidemiology (broad) | 0.004 | 0.006 |
| Bibliometrics | 0.006 | 0.004 |
| Science and technology studies | 0.002 | 0.003 |
| Scholarly communication | 0.004 | 0.002 |
| Open science | 0.007 | 0.005 |
| Research integrity | 0.011 | 0.010 |
| Insufficient payload (model declined to judge) | 0.003 | 0.005 |
Machine scores (provisional)
The two teacher heads of the student model, read on this work. A score orders the frame for review; it never asserts a category, and the validation status ships verbatim with every row.
Baseline scores from an immature model (maturity gate not passed, 7 training rounds). Scores rank; they never assert a category.
score_only:v0-immature-baseline · verbatim from the scoring run: score_only means the number may rank works, and no category label ships from itClassification
machine, unvalidatedMachine predicted; a candidate call from one source (direct Gemma or distilled Codex), not a consensus.
How this classification was reached, model by model and score by score, is at the end of the page under "How this classification was reached".