Comment on egusphere-2025-1106

Abstract. Mediterranean climate is characterised by a strong seasonality, critical for the ecosystems and societies in the region and is susceptible to climate change. The timing of when the Mediterranean climate developed over the past few thousand years remains a complex and unresolved question. Most studies document a part of the Mediterranean area or are based on a single (and frequently different) climate reconstruction method which can lead to non-negligible biases when considering climate changes on a Mediterranean scale. Several climate summaries based on pollen data have recently been produced on a European scale. However, none of them has focused exclusively on the Mediterranean area, except two recent syntheses documenting the eastern and western parts of the Mediterranean basin. We aimed to document the climate changes of the central Mediterranean during the Holocene, the trends and the different patterns. A robust methodology has been applied to 38 pollen records spreading across the south of France and Italy. Four climate reconstruction methods based on different mathematical and ecological concepts have been tested (MAT, WA-PLS, BRT and RF) and the selection of the best modern calibration dataset has also been investigated to produce the most reliable results. Particular attention has been paid to the seasonal nature of climatic parameters (winter and summer temperatures and precipitations). A model-data comparison has been made using transient model simulation TraCE-21ka in an attempt to gain a better understanding of the climate mechanisms and their forcing. Our palaeoclimate reconstruction shows that during the mid Holocene, summer temperatures were colder in the southern part of the central Mediterranean region albeit associated with positive anomalies, which is in accordance with the summer temperature reconstructions of the Iberian peninsula and eastern Mediterranean for the mid Holocene. In northern parts of the central Mediterranean region, and particularly in high elevation (> 1000 m), a Holocene thermal maximum is present, contrasting with the cold summer temperature anomalies previously reconstructed with pollen data for the Mediterranean region. Holocene summer conditions were characterised by specific spatio-temporal patterns, i.e., a west-east differentiation in southern France and a north-south one in Italy, for both temperature and precipitation. Holocene winter conditions showed a more homogeneous spatio-temporal pattern, i.e., general humidification and warming through the Holocene for Italy and southern France. A data-model simulation comparison shows a mostly coherent signal in winter but an incoherent one in summer. Those discrepancies between model simulations and pollen-based reconstructions suggest that during the Holocene, the northern Mediterranean climate was already subject to a marked spatio-temporal variability, particularly in summer, that cannot only be explained by changes in orbital configuration and atmospheric greenhouse gas evolution. Finally, our result highlighted the onset of the "Mediterraneanization" of the central Mediterranean region, characterised by wet winters and dry summers, after 8,000 years BP. The "Mediterraneanization" process seems to have had a greater impact on the southern regions than on the northern regions.

Fetched live from OpenAlex and de-inverted. Abstracts are not stored in this database: the inverted indexes are 8.6 GB of the frame’s 9.3 GB of text, and the host has 13 GB free.