APPENDIX 4 in Cranial morphology and phylogenetic relationships of Amynodontidae Scott & Osborn, 1883 (Perissodactyla, Rhinocerotoidea)
Bibliographic record
Abstract
APPENDIX 4. — The list of transformations. Simple arrow (-->) indicates an ambiguous change; double arrow (==>) indicates a synapomorphy/autapomorphy (green coloured cells). Data were obtained with the “describe trees” command of PAUP*. See Appendix 5 for corresponding of nodes with the parsimonious tree. Abbreviation: CI, consistency index. BranchCharacterStepsCIChange27811.0000 --> 128011.0000 ==> 128410.2861 --> 028610.2000 --> 1Node 37 --> Node 394710.6670 ==> 16010.2861 --> 27210.5000 --> 19510.2500 --> 19910.1431 --> 010210.3330 --> 110810.2501 --> 010910.2001 --> 011010.2141 ==> 211810.1430 ==> 111910.3330 ==> 114410.3331 --> 014720.4292 --> 028310.4000 --> 128710.3330 ==> 128910.1672 ==> 1Node 39 --> Node 403710.1430 --> 15510.2500 ==> 19211.0000 --> 111410.1582 --> 312110.1670 ==> 114610.3331 --> 014810.5000 ==> 115130.3000 ==> 315220.3332 --> 015810.5000 --> 117910.5001 --> 019810.5000 --> 120110.3330 ==> 120710.3330 ==> 122111.0000 --> 122820.5000 ==> 224110.3330 --> 125310.5000 --> 125911.0000 --> 126320.3001 --> 3Node 40 --> Node 432410.3330 --> 16010.2862 --> 16310.4000 ==> 18920.2500 ==> 29710.5000 ==> 110310.2001 --> 018031.0000 --> 318310.5000 --> 118510.5000 --> 119011.0001 --> 219110.5000 --> 121210.2501 ==> 024711.0000 ==> 125220.5000 ==> 227611.0000 --> 128511.0000 ==> 129711.0000 --> 1Node 43 --> Node 44710.2500 --> 11610.3331 --> 06310.4001 ==> 26711.0000 --> 18810.5000 --> 19110.4000 ==> 19410.4292 ==> 010210.3331 ==> 011010.2142 ==> 111420.1583 ==> 111810.1431 ==> 06510.1430 --> 128810.3330 ==> 1Node 62 --> Node 611010.1670 ==> 13810.5001 ==> 05310.1431 --> 05410.3331 --> 25610.1671 --> 06010.2861 --> 014910.3330 --> 115930.1670 --> 328910.1672 ==> 1Node 61 --> Metamynodon planifrons Scott & Osborn, 188710210.3330 ==> 211110.5000 ==> 111210.3330 ==> 112010.1250 --> 1Node 61 --> UNISTRA.2015.0.11061311.0000 ==> 14510.2500 ==> 19910.1430 ==> 110310.2002 --> 111420.1581 ==> 311711.0000 ==> 112110.1671 ==> 029210.3332 ==> 0Node 60 --> Node 593710.1431 ==> 06110.3330 --> 110510.1880 --> 121210.2500 --> 125610.2501 --> 027410.3330 --> 129010.2001 --> 029310.4000 ==> 1Node 59 --> Megalamynodon regalis Wood, 19454810.2500 ==> 15610.1671 ==> 07710.5000 ==> 110210.3330 ==> 211210.3330 ==> 128410.2862 ==> 1Node 59 --> Paramynodon birmanicus (Pilgrim & Cotter, 2016)5310.1431 ==> 09810.2500 ==> 111410.1581 ==> 015010.2500 ==> 115920.1670 ==> 229110.2501 --> 0Node 58 --> Node 57 (Cadurcodontini Wall, 1982)3410.1671 --> 04210.4001 ==> 26611.0000 --> 18330.2003 ==> 011810.1430 --> 119310.5000 ==> 119810.5001 --> 020210.5000 --> 124510.5000 --> 128710.3331 ==> 028810.3330 ==> 1Node 57 --> Node 541010.1670 --> 11210.2001 --> 01910.2502 --> 12310.2501 ==> 07710.5000 --> 112410.5000 ==> 112710.5000 ==> 119210.5001 ==> 023810.3331 --> 024610.5000 --> 125510.5000 --> 129210.3332 --> 129410.2500 ==> 1Node 54 --> Node 501110.2500 --> 11910.2501 --> 02111.0000 --> 17810.3330 --> 18110.2500 --> 18910.2501 --> 211420.1581 ==> 314910.3330 --> 116110.4001 ==> 228710.3330 --> 1Node 52 --> Cadurcotherium cayluxi Gervais, 187310310.2000 --> 112710.5001 ==> 028810.3331 ==> 0Node 52 --> Cadurcotherium minum Filhol, 18808330.2000 ==> 3Node 57 --> Node 56210.2501 --> 02520.6670 --> 23610.2860 --> 13710.1431 ==> 05610.1671 --> 09910.1430 --> 110920.2003 --> 111410.1581 ==> 212010.1250 --> 125410.2000 --> 125610.2501 --> 028610.2001 --> 029310.4000 --> 129811.0000 ==> 1Node 56 --> Node 555310.1431 --> 29110.4002 --> 19810.2500 --> 111410.1582 --> 315310.6672 --> 128910.1672 ==> 129510.2862 --> 1Node 55 --> ZSN-KKS-28-IPB10310.2001 ==> 210410.2500 ==> 110530.1880 ==> 310810.2500 ==> 113711.0000 ==> 1Node 56 --> Zaisanamynodon protheroi Lucas, 200614810.5001 ==> 0Node 47 --> Sharamynodon mongoliensis (Osborn, 1936)5310.1431 ==> 25510.2501 ==> 07010.5001 --> 09810.2500 ==> 111410.1581 ==> 014110.2500 ==> 120910.5000 ==> 127120.3332 ==> 028310.4002 ==> 128410.2862 ==> 1Node 46 --> Amynodon advenus (Marsh, 1875)210.2501 --> 03710.1431 ==> 04810.2500 ==> 15310.1431 ==> 06010.2861 ==> 09910.1430 ==> 110510.1880 ==> 115010.2500 ==> 115621.0000 ==> 215920.1670 ==> 216010.2500 ==> 1Node 45 --> Rostriamynodon grangeri Wall & Manning, 19865610.1671 ==> 011010.2141 ==> 012010.1251 ==> 014010.4001 ==> 229310.4000 ==> 210530.1880 ==> 311220.3330 ==> 217811.0000 ==> 118110.5000 --> 118221.0000 ==> 227510.3330 ==> 128310.4001 --> 028610.2001 --> 029010.2000 ==> 1Node 39 --> Node 38 (Eggysodontidae Breuning, 1923)710.2500 --> 11110.2501 --> 05310.1431 --> 09410.4292 ==> 110310.2001 ==> 213310.3330 ==> 115720.2502 --> 016010.2500 --> 120210.5000 --> 121710.5000 --> 124910.5000 --> 126310.3001 --> 026810.5000 ==> 127110.3332 --> 128310.4001 --> 228420.2860 ==> 229110.2500 --> 1Node 38 --> Allacerops turgaica (Borissiak, 1915)6310.4000 ==> 18910.2500 ==> 110530.1880 ==> 314010.4001 ==> 214110.2500 ==> 115510.3330 ==> 1Node 38 --> Eggysodon osborni Schlosser, 19029510.2501 --> 011420.1582 ==> 013810.2501 --> 015410.3331 ==> 021110.3330 ==> 121210.2501 ==> 022410.5000 ==> 125610.2500 ==> 127210.5000 ==> 1Node 37 --> Teletaceras radinskyi Hanson, 1989110.5000 ==> 13610.2861 ==> 04610.5000 ==> 16510.1430 ==> 17910.5000 ==> 18330.2000 ==> 39410.4292 ==> 310410.2500 ==> 110920.2001 ==> 311110.5000 ==> 114710.4292 ==> 315410.3331 ==> 015930.1670 ==> 329410.2500 --> 1Node 36 --> Node 351810.5000 --> 11910.2501 ==> 02010.2861 --> 26310.4000 ==> 114310.5001 ==> 016510.5001 ==> 018810.3330 --> 119910.3330 --> 121810.5000 ==> 122711.0000 --> 124211.0001 ==> 025011.0001 ==> 0Node 35 --> Node 34 (Rhinocerotidae Gray, 1821)1010.1671 --> 02310.2500 --> 14410.3330 ==> 1Branch CharacterStepsCIChange6110.3330 ==> 16310.4001 ==> 09410.4292 ==> 110210.3332 ==> 310510.1881 ==> 210810.2501 ==> 011210.3331 ==> 211810.1431 --> 014710.4292 ==> 115710.2501 ==> 015920.1672 --> 019410.5000 ==> 119920.3331 ==> 321810.5001 ==> 023011.0001 ==> 223810.3331 --> 026110.3331 ==> 226510.6670 ==> 1Node 33 --> Aceratherium incisivum (Cuvier, 1824)1711.0000 ==> 11910.2500 ==> 12310.2501 --> 02911.0000 ==> 13410.1670 ==> 15410.3330 ==> 18610.3330 ==> 19510.2500 ==> 19910.1431 --> 010011.0000 ==> 110121.0000 ==> 210310.2001 ==> 210910.2001 ==> 211110.5002 ==> 311311.0000 ==> 111410.1580 ==> 111531.0000 ==> 312210.5000 ==> 112511.0000 ==> 112911.0000 ==> 113310.3330 ==> 113411.0000 ==> 113521.0000 ==> 213810.2500 --> 114010.4001 ==> 014210.3330 ==> 114610.3330 ==> 115010.2500 ==> 115110.3000 ==> 115220.3330 ==> 216010.2500 --> 116110.4000 ==> 119310.5000 ==> 119610.5000 ==> 120110.3330 ==> 120411.0000 ==> 120511.0000 ==> 120611.0000 ==> 120710.3330 ==> 121011.0000 ==> 121310.3330 --> 121611.0000 ==> 122410.5000 ==> 122620.5000 ==> 223211.0000 ==> 124410.5000 --> 124510.5000 ==> 125111.0000 ==> 125410.2000 ==> 1Node 35 --> Hyrachyus eximius Leidy, 18711610.3331 --> 05310.1431 --> 06010.2861 ==> 2
Fetched live from OpenAlex and de-inverted. Abstracts are not stored in this database: the inverted indexes are 8.6 GB of the frame’s 9.3 GB of text, and the host has 13 GB free.
How this classification was reachedexpand
Full frame machine prediction
Teacher imitationNot calibrated prevalence, not ground truth. Human validation pending. The Gemma side is a direct model label for every work in the frame, read from the title-only record. The Codex side is a classifier learned from the 10,348 direct Codex labels and calibrated to design-weighted sample rates; fields without enough sample support carry no Codex call. Candidate is the union of the two sides; consensus is their intersection. These outputs are machine_predicted_unvalidated and are not human labels.
Distilled classifier scores by category (both heads)
| Category | Codex | Gemma |
|---|---|---|
| Metaresearch | 0.000 | 0.005 |
| Meta-epidemiology (narrow) | 0.001 | 0.001 |
| Meta-epidemiology (broad) | 0.001 | 0.001 |
| Bibliometrics | 0.005 | 0.006 |
| Science and technology studies | 0.001 | 0.000 |
| Scholarly communication | 0.001 | 0.001 |
| Open science | 0.001 | 0.001 |
| Research integrity | 0.001 | 0.001 |
| Insufficient payload (model declined to judge) | 0.609 | 0.185 |
Machine scores (provisional)
The two teacher heads of the student model, read on this work. A score orders the frame for review; it never asserts a category, and the validation status ships verbatim with every row.
Baseline scores from an immature model (maturity gate not passed, 7 training rounds). Scores rank; they never assert a category.
score_only:v0-immature-baseline · verbatim from the scoring run: score_only means the number may rank works, and no category label ships from itClassification
machine, unvalidatedMachine predicted; a candidate call from one source (direct Gemma or distilled Codex), not a consensus.
How this classification was reached, model by model and score by score, is at the end of the page under "How this classification was reached".