A Big Thank You to Our Reviewers in The Past Year!
Bibliographic record
Abstract
Good reviewers are essential to the success of any journal and peer review is a major pillar of science. We are grateful to those mentioned below to have dedicated their time and expertise to help our authors improve and refine their manuscripts and support the Editors in the decision making process in the past year. The following received our Top Reviewer of the Year Award: Prof. Bergheim Ina, Austria Dr. Gancheva Sofiya, Germany Dr. Papanas Nikolaos, Greece Dr. Acıbucu Fettah, Turkey Dr. Ahmed Marwan A., Germany Prof. Akamizu Takashi, Japan Dr. Altieri Barbara, Germany Dr. Altinova Alev, Turkey Dr. Altun Burak, Turkey Dr. Andrew Toby, UK Dr. Angele Claudia, Austria Prof. Anichini Roberto, Italy Dr. Anil Cuneyd, Turkey Prof. Antonelli Alessandro, Italy Mrs. Apostolopoulou Maria, Germany Dr. Arya Dharamvir Singh, India Dr. Aulinger Benedikt, Germany Dr. Balkau Beverley, Germany Dr. Balta Sevket, Germany Prof. Barrett Eugene, Germany Dr. Bechmann Nicole, Germany Prof. Beer-Hammer Sandra, Germany Dr. Belgardt Bengt-Frederik, Germany Dr. Ben-Menahem D., Israel Prof. Bergheim Ina, Austria Dr. Berti Lucia, Germany Dr. Beuschlein Felix, Germany Dr. Beyerlein Andreas, Germany Dr. Bidlingmaer Martin, Germany Prof. Birkenfeld Andreas, Germany Prof. Bloch Wilhelm, Germany Prof. Blüher Matthias, Germany Prof. Blum Marcus, Germany Dr. Bobby Zachariah, India Dr. Bodde Mathijs C., The Netherlands Dr. Bogazzi F., Italy Prof. Bojunga Jörg, Germany Prof. Bollheimer Cornelius, Germany Dr. Brabant Georg, Germany Dr. Breit Andreas, Germany Prof. Brun J. -F., Germany Dr. Bunz Hanno, Germany Dr. Buraczynska Monika, Germany Dr. Burrello Jacopo, Italy Prof. Buyken Anette, Germany Prof. Çakır Bekir, Turkey Dr. Calabresi Laura, Italy Prof. Calafiore Riccardo, Germany Dr. Cambri Lucieli Teresa, Brazil Dr. Campbel Jeffrey, USA Dr. Canpolat Ugur, Turkey Dr. Cansu Güven, Turkey Dr. Carey Andrew L., Australia Dr. Celec Peter, Slovakia Dr. Cervantes-García Estrella, Mexico Dr. Chai Young Jun, Korea Prof. Chanson Philippe, France Prof. Chen Ta-Liang, Germany Prof. Chodick Gabriel, Israel Prof. Claahsen Hedi, The Netherlands Dr. Claahsen-van der Grinten Hedi L., Germany Prof. Clark Adrian, UK Dr. Consitt Leslie, USA Dr. Daniel Carolin, Germany Dr. Danser A. H. Jan, The Netherlands Dr. Delanghe Joris R., Belgium Prof. Desoye G., Germany Dr. Deutschbein Thilo, Germany Dr. Di Tucci Chiara, Italy Prof. Dimitriadis George, Greece Dr. Dintsios Markos, Germany Prof. Dralle Henning, Germany Prof. Duntas Leonidas, Greece Dr. Eckstein Sabine, Germany Prof. Eisenhofer Graeme, Germany Prof. Erckenbrecht Joachim F., Germany Prof. Erdogan Mehmet, Turkey Dr. Eriksson Jan F., Sweden Dr. Essop M. Faadiel, South Africa Prof. Fadini Gian Paolo, Italy Prof. Fasshauer Mathias, Germany Dr. Fehlert Ellen, Germany Dr. Franko Andras, Germany Dr. Fritsche Louise, Germany Dr. Galasso Gennaro, Germany Prof. Gallwitz Baptist, Germany Dr. Gancheva Sofiya, Germany Prof. Gärtner Roland, Germany Prof. Gastaldi Giacomo, Switzerland Dr. Gomez-Sanchez Celso, Germany Dr. Grino Michel, France Dr. Groener Jan, Germany Prof. Grzesk Grzegorz, Poland Prof. Gudermann Thomas, Germany Dr. Guillou Hervé, France Dr. Guo Yongqing, China Dr. Gupta Sumeet, India Dr. Guthoff Martina, Germany Miss Haag Stefanie, Germany Prof. Hallschmid Manfred, Germany Prof. Häring Hans Ulrich, Germany Dr. Heise Tim, Germany Dr. Heni Martin, Germany Dr. Herder Christian, Germany Dr. Hoffmann Christoph, Germany Dr. Holst Jens J., Germany Dr. Holzapfel Christina, Germany Prof. Honegger Jürgen, Germany Dr. Hosseinsabet Ali, Iran Dr. Hubacek Jaroslav A, Czech Republic Prof. Icks Andrea, Germany Dr. Irwin N., Germany Dr. Isenovic Esma R., Serbia Dr. Jain Deepanshu, USA Dr. Jelenik Tomas, Germany Dr. Juarez Camacho Patricia, Mexico Prof. Kahaly Georg, Germany Dr. Kanazawa Ippei, Japan Dr. Kantartzis Konstantinos, Germany Dr. Kapellen Thomas, Germany Dr. Karaköse Esra, USA Prof. Kastelan Darko, Croatia Dr. Kempe-Teufel Daniela, Germany Dr. Khajavi Noushafarin, Germany Prof. Kim Won Gu, Korea Dr. Kimmel Martin, Germany Dr. Kimura Nobuyuki, Japan Dr. King James A., UK Prof. Kinne Rolf Karl-Heinz, Germany Dr. Kisseljak-Vassiliades Katja, USA Dr. Klegeris Andis, Canada Dr. Kleinridders André, Germany Dr. Kleinwechter Helmut, Germany Dr. Klisic Aleksandra, Montenegro Prof. Klose Gerald Germany Dr. Knappe Ulrich, Germany Prof. Komocsi Andras, Germany Dr. Konrad Marcel, Germany Dr. Kopf Stefan, Germany Prof. Kratzsch Jürgen, Germany Dr. Kroiss Matthias, Germany Dr. Krone Nils, UK Dr. Krysiak Robert, Poland Dr. Kullmann Stephanie, Germany Dr. Kupai Krisztina, Hungary Prof. Kuß Oliver, Germany Dr. Lagali Neil S., Sweden Dr. Laguna Egea Juan Carlos, Spain Prof. Lange Karin, Germany Prof. Lázaro Martínez José Luis, Spain Dr. Lechner Andreas, Germany Dr. Lehn-Stefan Angela, Germany Dr. Lemos Manuel C., Germany Prof. Lenders Jacques, Germany Prof. Lenders Jacques, The Netherlands Dr. Lerario Antonio, USA Prof. Leung Siu-wai, Germany Prof. Lewinski Andrzej, Poland Dr. Li Xiaoqiang, Germany Dr. Li Yuanying, Japan Dr. Li Huixi, China Prof. Lim PY, Malaysia Dr. Liu Zong-yang, China Dr. Long Yang, China Prof. Lorenzo O., Spain Dr. Lutz Stefan, Germany Dr. Ma Rong, Germany Dr. Ma Yongsheng, Germany Dr. Machann Jürgen, Germany Dr. Malik Rayaz A., USA Dr. Manes Christos, Greece Prof. Mann Giovanni, UK Prof. Mantero Franco, Italy Dr. Mazhar Kehkashan, Pakistan Dr. Mert Meral, Germany Prof. Metwalley Kotb Abbass, Egypt Dr. Meyer Gesine, Germany Prof. Mithieux Gilles, France Dr. Monastiriotis Christodoulos, Greece Dr. Monastra Giovanni, Italy Dr. Monnerat Gustavo, Brazil Prof. Monteiro-Soares M., Germany Dr. Müller Nicole, Germany Dr. Na Risu, Germany Dr. Nagalakshmi C.S., India Prof. Nauck Michael, Germany Prof. Nieß Andreas, Germany Dr. Othman Maha, Germany Dr. Ouchi Motoshi, Japan Dr. ozkan zeynep, Turkey Dr. Panebianco Federica, USA Dr. Paoli Paolo, Italy Dr. Papanas Nikolaos, Greece Dr. Papazafiropoulou Athanasia, Greece Dr. Pardina Eva, Spain Dr. Párrizas Marcelina, Spain Dr. Pawaskar Manjiri, USA Prof. Pedro-Botet Juan, Spain Dr. Pentzek Michael, Germany Dr. Pepe Jessica, Germany Dr. Peter Andreas, Germany Dr. Petersenn Stephan, Germany Prof. Petrovic Daniel, Slovenia Prof. Pfützner Andreas, Germany Dr. Pinho Roberto C. M., Brazil Dr. Planck Tereza, Sweden Mr. Pleus Stefan, Germany Dr. Pontiroli Antonio E., Italy Dr. Qinkler Marcus, Germany Prof. Raasch Walter, Germany Dr. Ramkumar K.M., India Dr. Randrianarisoa Elko, Germany Prof. Raposo Joao, Portugal Dr. Raptis Athanasios, Greece Prof. Raue Friedhelm, Germany Mrs. Rayes Nada, Germany Prof. Reincke Martin, Germany Dr. Renner Simone, Germany Dr. Retnakaran Ravi, Canada Dr. Rice Suman, UK Prof. Rizzo Manfredi, Italy Dr. Rudnicki Michael, Austria Prof. Rustenbeck I., Germany Dr. Sakitani Kosuke, Japan Dr. Santovito Donato, Germany Prof. Sasase Tomohiko, Japan Prof. Saxena Sandeep, Germany Prof. Schaaf Ludwig, Germany Dr. Schilbach Katharina, Germany Prof. Schleicher E., Germany Dr. Schlesinger Sabrina, Germany Dr. Schöbel Christoph, Germany Prof. Schopohl Jochen, Germany Dr. Schork Anja, Germany Dr. Schuurman Henk-Jan, The Netherlands Dr. Sell Henrike, Germany Dr. Shestakova Marina V., Germany Dr. Shi Xiaoguang, China Dr. Shin J, Korea Dr. Shinohara Masakazu, Japan Dr. Shivaprasad Channabasappa, India Dr. Simon Marie-Christine, Germany Dr. Spitzweg Christine, Germany Prof. Stalla Günter, Germany Dr. Stanik Juraj, Slovakia Prof. Stefan Norbert, Germany Dr. Stefanic M., Croatia Prof. Strasburger C., Germany Dr. Stratmann Bernd, Germany Dr. Suarez Jorge, Germany Prof. Sun Liang, China Dr. Tada Hayato, Japan Dr. Takata Tomoyo, Japan Dr. Tan Bee K, UK Dr. Tang Yifan, China Prof. Tentolouris Nicholas, Greece Dr. Tentolouris Anastasios, Greece Prof. Terzolo Massimo, Italy Dr. Tessem Jeffery S., USA Prof. Tkac Ivan, Slovakia Dr. Toenjes Anke, Germany Dr. Torsoni A. S., Germany Dr. Tsentidis C., Germany Prof. Ucar Tayfun, Turkey Prof. Ullrich Susanne, Germany Dr. Uzum Ayse, Turkey Dr. van Raalte Daniel, The Netherlands Dr. Varga Tibor, Sweden Dr. Vargas Jay R., USA Dr. Vaughan Camille P., USA Prof. von Bergen Martin, Germany Dr. von Hauff Elizabeth, The Netherlands Dr. Vujasinovic Miroslav, Sweden Dr. Wagner Robert, Germany Dr. Waldmann Elisa, Germany Dr. Wang Jian, China Dr. Wang Jianxiong, Australia Dr. Wang Yufei, China Prof. Wass John, UK Dr. Weber Katharina, Germany Prof. Weigert Cora, Germany Dr. Willmann Caroline, Germany Dr. Wong Chi Kin, Canada Dr. Wu Reen, USA Prof. Xu Zhijie, China Dr. Yang Tao, Germany Dr. Yavuzer Serap, Turkey Dr. Yilmaz Özgür, Turkey Dr. Yu Xuemei, China Dr. Zanelli Santina A., USA Dr. Zhang Lin, China Dr. Zhang Hong, China Dr. Zhang Wenjian, China Prof. Ziegler Anette-Gabriele, Germany
Fetched live from OpenAlex and de-inverted. Abstracts are not stored in this database: the inverted indexes are 8.6 GB of the frame’s 9.3 GB of text, and the host has 13 GB free.
How this classification was reachedexpand
Full frame distilled prediction
Teacher imitationNot calibrated prevalence, not ground truth. Human validation pending. Learned from the 10,348 direct Codex labels and 10,348 direct Gemma labels. Candidate is the union of thresholded teacher heads; consensus is their intersection. These outputs are machine_predicted_unvalidated and are not human labels or direct frontier model labels.
Codex and Gemma teacher scores by category
| Category | Codex | Gemma |
|---|---|---|
| Metaresearch | 0.000 | 0.000 |
| Meta-epidemiology (narrow) | 0.000 | 0.000 |
| Meta-epidemiology (broad) | 0.000 | 0.000 |
| Bibliometrics | 0.000 | 0.000 |
| Science and technology studies | 0.000 | 0.000 |
| Scholarly communication | 0.000 | 0.000 |
| Open science | 0.000 | 0.000 |
| Research integrity | 0.000 | 0.000 |
| Insufficient payload (model declined to judge) | 0.000 | 0.000 |
Machine scores (provisional)
The two teacher heads of the student model, read on this work. A score orders the frame for review; it never asserts a category, and the validation status ships verbatim with every row.
Baseline scores from an immature model (maturity gate not passed, 7 training rounds). Scores rank; they never assert a category.
score_only:v0-immature-baseline · verbatim from the scoring run: score_only means the number may rank works, and no category label ships from itClassification
machine, unvalidatedMachine predicted; a candidate call from one teacher head, not a consensus.
How this classification was reached, model by model and score by score, is at the end of the page under "How this classification was reached".