Challenging the myth of ‘Minority White Cities’

Whites will soon become a minority in Birmingham and other major British cities, posing a critical challenge to social stability, Britain’s race relations watchdog has warned. The Sunday Times newspaper Introduction Concerns about the consequences of immigration and residential segregation converge in a spectre of ‘Minority White Cities’, where White residents make up less than half of the population. There is a fascination with the year in which particular cities will lose their White majority both from those whose work encourages ethnic diversity and those who fear lack of integration. Thus, publicity from a global forum on Cities in Transition was headlined by the wholly unsubstantiated claim that ‘Birmingham is set to join Toronto and Los Angeles as a “majority-minority city” by 2011’ in order to raise questions for planning: ‘What will it mean for public services and race relations when more than half the population is non-White?’ Similarly, the Commission for Racial Equality’s factual profiles based on the 2001 Census and prepared in 2006 claim that ‘Leicester is widely predicted, within the next five years, to become the first city in Europe with a majority non-white population. Nowhere else in Britain has proportionally fewer White British residents’. Here ‘widely predicted’ needs to be interpreted as ‘predicted wide of the mark’ as no such predictions have been made. The coolly stated ‘fact’ of Leicester’s extremely low proportion of White British residents is also false. In 2007 a contributor to Wikipedia, a widely used free online encyclopaedia edited by its readers, used six such apparently authoritative reports to claim that ‘The indigenous population is due to be a minority in Leicester, London and in Birmingham by the time of the 2011 Census’. Two claims about Minority White Cities are addressed in this chapter. First, that the phenomenon of a Minority White City has some democratic meaning or significance for city management. Second, that population change will be such that several British cities will have fewer than half their residents of White ethnicities by 2011. The chapter examines the predictions and puts the evidence beside them, which demonstrates severe exaggeration. First, we argue that the notion of cities becoming plural in the near future (where no one racial or ethnic group has a majority) is simply a convenient hook on which to hang discussion of the challenges and opportunities of future multicultural cities.

Fetched live from OpenAlex and de-inverted. Abstracts are not stored in this database: the inverted indexes are 8.6 GB of the frame’s 9.3 GB of text, and the host has 13 GB free.