MétaCan

1,000 works · Opus 4.8 · GPT-5.6 (high) · Grok 4.5 · one locked rubric

The field’s boundary is not a line. It is a region.

Three frontier models screened the same 1,000 works, drawn from the real frame with known selection probabilities, against the same locked rubric on its full eight-field payload. Of the 51 works any model called metaresearch, only 19 (37.3%) were called metaresearch by all three, and 24 (47.1%) rest on a single model's opinion.

Two screeners can agree on a rate while finding almost entirely different works. At a ~1% base rate, the settled rejects buy 98% agreement for free — which is why an agreement statistic computed over the whole sample tells you nothing about the boundary, and why the table below, not a percentage, is the deliverable.

Any model said metaresearch
51
the disagreement dossier: the field's empirical boundary
All three agreed
19
37.3% of the dossier — the settled core
Two of three
8
contested
One model only
24
47.1% of the dossier rests on one model's opinion

The three models are not interchangeable

How many of the 1,000 works each model called metaresearch (tier T1 or T2), on identical input. T3 is adjacent and does not count as in scope, which is why a model's count can never exceed the 51 works in the dossier.

Claude Opus 4.8
42
GPT-5.6 (high)
31
Grok 4.5
24

Swap which model you call “the screener” and the size of the field moves. That spread — not the binomial confidence interval on any one model's labels — is the honest uncertainty on how big Canadian metaresearch is.

The disagreement dossier

All three verdicts, confidences and reasons side by side. These are the works against which the inclusion criteria have to be written — because these are the works on which reasonable screeners, given the same rubric and the same evidence, disagree.

1,000 works
WorkStratumn_inOpus 4.8GPT-5.6Grok 4.5
31. Les intellectuels catholiques et l'université moderne
2002 · book-chapter · fr · Presses de l’Université de Montréal eBooks
french
w=1554
0/3OUTlow
conceptual

Intellectual-history chapter on a Catholic thinker's vision of faith, science and the university; touches the limits of science but is religious intellectual history, not a study of contemporary research practice.

OUThigh
conceptual

This discusses Catholic intellectuals, faith, science, and the university rather than research practice itself.

OUTmedium
conceptual

Historical-theological discussion of Catholic intellectuals in the modern university, not contemporary research practice.

Of Traiteurs and Tsars
2018 · article · en · Historical Reflections/Réflexions Historiques
venue_new
w=2684
0/3OUThigh
empirical

Cultural history of Parisian catering and Franco-Russian gala banquets; the object is culinary and diplomatic history.

OUThigh
conceptual

This historical study concerns French catering, diplomacy, and technology rather than research practice.

OUThigh
conceptual

Cultural history of Franco-Russian diplomatic banquets and catering; not research practice.

21. Louis XVI, le Congrès américain et le Canada 1774-1789
2006 · book-chapter · fr · Presses de l’Université de Montréal eBooks
french
w=1554
0/3OUTmedium
empirical

Diplomatic history of Louis XVI, the American Congress and Canada; the abstract excerpt is a preface on historical erudition, but the object of the work is eighteenth-century history.

OUThigh
conceptual

This is a historical study of Louis XVI, the American Congress, and Canada, not research itself.

OUThigh
empirical

Eighteenth-century political history of Louis XVI, Congress, and Canada; object is diplomacy, not research.

Exploratory Analysis of Biometric Data Concerning Characteristics of Urucum (Bixa orellana L.) in the Northeast of Brazil
2019 · article · en · Journal of Agricultural Science
venue_new
w=2684
0/3OUThigh
empirical

Biometric analysis of annatto seeds; agronomy.

OUThigh
empirical

This study measures plant seed characteristics and does not study research methods.

OUThigh
empirical

Biometric measurement of urucum seeds; agronomic domain study, not research methods as object.

L’aménagement durable du territoire et la participation citoyenne : une relation à penser
2018 · article · fr · Cahiers de géographie du Québec
french
w=1554
0/3OUTmedium
conceptual

Essay on sustainable land planning and citizen participation; the object is planning practice.

OUTlow
conceptual

The title concerns sustainable territorial planning and citizen participation, with no abstract indicating research as the object.

OUTmedium
conceptual

Sustainable territorial planning and citizen participation is planning/geography, not research practice.

A step-wise synthetic approach is necessary to access γ-conjugates of folate: folate-conjugated prodigiosenes
2019 · article · en · RSC Advances
aff_core
w=5595
0/3OUThigh
empirical

Synthetic chemistry paper on folate-conjugated prodigiosenes; the object is a synthetic route.

OUThigh
empirical

The paper develops synthetic routes for folate conjugates rather than studying research practice.

OUThigh
empirical

Synthetic organic chemistry of folate-conjugated prodigiosenes.

Circadian Patterns of Ingestion and Rumination in Ruminants: A Chronophysiological Review
2019 · review · en · Journal of Buffalo Science
venue_new
w=2684
0/3OUThigh
empirical

Review of circadian feeding physiology in ruminants; synthesis of domain findings.

OUThigh
other

This review concerns feeding and rumination biology in ruminants, not research.

OUThigh
conceptual

Chronophysiology review of ruminant feeding and rumination patterns.

Bilan de la libre circulation des personnes en Afrique
2017 · article · fr · Interventions économiques
french
w=1554
0/3OUThigh
conceptual

Assessment of free movement of persons in African economic integration; a policy question in its own domain, not research policy.

OUThigh
conceptual

This analyzes migration and economic integration policy in Africa, not research practice.

OUThigh
policy

Policy analysis of free movement of persons in African regional integration; not research systems.

Nous, and: Architecture
2019 · article · en · ˜The œSewanee review
about_only
w=3321
0/3OUThigh
other

Published poems; not research.

OUThigh
other

This is a literary poem with no focus on research itself.

OUThigh
other

Literary poetry; not a study of research.

FRI0452 TOFACITINIB IN PATIENTS WITH PSORIATIC ARTHRITIS: ANALYSIS OF DERMATOLOGIC ENDPOINTS FROM 2 PHASE 3 STUDIES
2019 · article · en · Annals of the Rheumatic Diseases
aff_core
w=5595
0/3OUThigh
empirical

Conference abstract reporting dermatologic endpoints of tofacitinib from two phase 3 trials; a clinical efficacy analysis.

OUTlow
empirical

The title identifies a clinical treatment analysis, but the abstract is missing and provides insufficient detail.

OUThigh
empirical

Clinical phase-3 dermatologic endpoints for tofacitinib in psoriatic arthritis.

Sommes-nous de bons juges de notre stress? Marqueurs subjectifs et physiologiques de stress chez de jeunes adultes se disant ‘zen’ versus très stressés
2018 · dissertation · fr · Papyrus : Institutional Repository (Université de Montréal)
french
w=1554
0/3OUThigh
empirical

Psychoneuroendocrinology study of subjective versus physiological stress markers.

OUThigh
empirical

The dissertation studies subjective and physiological stress in adults rather than research practice.

OUThigh
empirical

Psychoneuroendocrine comparison of subjective and physiological stress; domain psychology, not metaresearch.

Welfare Maximization and Truthfulness in Mechanism Design with Ordinal Preferences
2013 · preprint · en · arXiv (Cornell University)
aff_core
w=5595
0/3OUThigh
empirical

Theoretical paper on welfare maximization and truthfulness in ordinal mechanism design.

OUThigh
conceptual

It develops mathematical mechanisms for voting and matching markets, not methods of research.

OUThigh
conceptual

Theoretical mechanism design and voting/matching markets; computational social choice, not research practice.

Sympatric speciation in the <i>Simulium arcticum</i> s. l. complex (Diptera: Simuliidae): The Rothfels model updated
2019 · article · en · Ecology and Evolution
aff_core
w=5595
0/3OUThigh
empirical

Tests a sympatric speciation model in black flies using sex-chromosome data; an evolutionary-biology question.

OUThigh
empirical

It tests a biological speciation model in black flies, not research itself.

OUThigh
empirical

Evolutionary genetics of black-fly speciation; organismal biology (open-data badge is incidental).

Formación profesional en ambientes e-learning. Estudio de caso sobre Aprendizaje Basado en Proyectos (ABP) en un curso de posgrado virtual
2019 · article · en · RELATEC Revista Latinoamericana de Tecnología Educativa
aff_core
w=5595
0/3OUThigh
empirical

Case study of project-based learning in an online postgraduate teacher-training course; educational pedagogy.

OUThigh
empirical

The work evaluates project-based learning in an e-learning course, not research itself.

OUThigh
empirical

Case study of project-based learning in an e-learning teacher-training course; educational pedagogy, not metaresearch.

Complement Markers in Blood and Urine: No Diagnostic Value in Late Silent Antibody-Mediated Rejection
2019 · article · en · Transplantation Direct
aff_core
w=5595
0/3OUThigh
empirical

Cross-sectional study of complement markers for diagnosing antibody-mediated kidney rejection; a clinical diagnostic question.

OUThigh
empirical

It evaluates diagnostic markers for kidney-transplant rejection, not research itself.

OUThigh
empirical

Diagnostic value of complement markers in kidney transplant rejection; clinical nephrology.

Differences in the Rotation Axes of the Scapholunate Joint During Flexion-Extension and Radial-Ulnar Deviation Motions
2019 · article · en · The Journal Of Hand Surgery
aff_core
w=5595
0/3OUThigh
empirical

Biomechanics of scapholunate joint rotation axes; clinical/anatomical study.

OUTlow
empirical

The abstract is missing and the title indicates a clinical biomechanics study rather than research about research.

OUThigh
empirical

Orthopaedic biomechanics of scapholunate joint motion; clinical anatomy, not research practice.

Assessment of diagnostic methods for imported malaria in mainland France
2019 · review · fr · Médecine et Maladies Infectieuses
french
w=1554
0/3OUTmedium
empirical

Assessment of diagnostic methods for imported malaria; diagnostic accuracy in clinical practice, no abstract available.

OUTlow
other

The title indicates a clinical review of malaria diagnostic methods, but the missing abstract prevents firmer judgment.

OUTlow
other

Title points to clinical assessment of malaria diagnostic methods; no abstract, domain medicine not metaresearch.

Effect of Goose Removals on a Suburban Canada Goose Population
2009 · article · en · Utah State Research and Scholarship (Utah State University)
about_only
w=3321
0/3OUThigh
empirical

Evaluation of a goose removal program; wildlife management.

OUThigh
empirical

The study evaluates goose-removal effects on an animal population, not research itself.

OUThigh
empirical

Wildlife management experiment on suburban Canada goose removals; ecology and pest control.

Capacity of an in vitro rat skin model to predict human dermal absorption: Influences of aging and anatomical site
2019 · article · en · Toxicology in Vitro
fund_new
w=1679
0/3OUTmedium
empirical

Evaluates an in vitro rat skin model's ability to predict human dermal absorption; a toxicology assay for a domain question.

OUThigh
empirical

It evaluates a skin model for predicting dermal absorption, not research practice.

OUThigh
empirical

Toxicology model predicting human dermal absorption; domain method validation, not research-on-research.

Burden and Standard of Proof in Election Petitions without Criminal Allegations
2019 · article · en · Journal of Politics and Law
venue_new
w=2684
0/3OUThigh
conceptual

Legal argument about burden and standard of proof in election petitions; 'evidence' and 'proof' here are legal, not research, concepts.

OUThigh
conceptual

The paper analyzes legal standards of proof in election petitions.

OUThigh
conceptual

Legal analysis of burden of proof in election petitions; electoral law, not research practice.

Using electronic health record data to establish a chronic kidney disease surveillance system in China: protocol for the China Kidney Disease Network (CK-NET)-Yinzhou Study
2019 · article · en · BMJ Open
fund_new
w=1679
0/3OUTmedium
empirical

Protocol for a kidney disease surveillance system built on health records; health surveillance infrastructure, not research infrastructure.

OUThigh
other

The protocol concerns a chronic-kidney-disease surveillance system and clinical decision support.

OUThigh
empirical

Protocol for CKD surveillance using Chinese EHR data is clinical epidemiology infrastructure, not study of research systems.

Influence of serum estradiol on serum uric acid level in pre and postmenopausal women.
2019 · article · en · The Professional Medical Journal
aff_core
w=5595
0/3OUThigh
empirical

Case-control clinical study of estradiol and uric acid levels.

OUThigh
empirical

The study examines estradiol and uric acid levels in menopausal women.

OUThigh
empirical

Clinical association of estradiol and uric acid in women; biomedical physiology.

Voir et montrer la mort animale
2019 · article · fr · Frontières
french
w=1554
0/3OUTmedium
conceptual

Essay on regimes of visibility of animal death; the reflexive note about the researcher's own gaze is secondary to an object that is cultural representation, not research practice.

OUThigh
conceptual

The object is the visibility of animal death in media and cultural practice, not research practice.

OUThigh
conceptual

Social analysis of visibility regimes around animal death; not about research as object.

Hardware Implementation of Barrett Reduction Exploiting Constant Multiplication
2019 · dissertation · en · UWSpace (University of Waterloo)
fund_new
w=1679
0/3OUThigh
empirical

Hardware implementation of Barrett modular reduction for elliptic curve cryptography; the object is a circuit design.

OUThigh
empirical

The dissertation develops hardware implementations for cryptographic arithmetic rather than studying research.

OUThigh
empirical

Hardware implementation of modular reduction for cryptography; computer engineering, not metaresearch.

LA RÉPONSE À L’INTERVENTION ET L’OFFRE DE SERVICES MULTIPALIERS POUR SOUTENIR L’INCLUSION SCOLAIRE : UN PARADOXE À VISÉE D’EXCLUSION DES ÉLÈVES EN SITUATION DE HANDICAP
2019 · article · fr · McGill Journal of Education / Revue des sciences de l éducation de McGill
french
w=1554
0/3OUTmedium
conceptual

Critical analysis of response-to-intervention and multi-tiered service delivery in school inclusion; the object is educational service provision for students with disabilities, not research practice, though its critique of evidence-based programs brushes against the boundary.

OUThigh
conceptual

This critical analysis concerns educational inclusion programs and disability, not the practice of research.

OUThigh
conceptual

Critical analysis of school inclusion and response-to-intervention programs; object is educational practice, not research.

When Things Don’t Fall Apart: Global Financial Governance and Developmental Finance in an Age of Productive Incoherence, By Ilene Grabel (2017) Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 400 pages. ISBN: 978-0-26253-852-7 Laid Low: Inside the Crisis that Overwhelmed Europe and the IMF, By Paul Blustein (2016) Waterloo, Ontario, Centre for International Governance Innovation, 504 pages. ISBN: 978-1-92809-633-7
2019 · article · en · Relations industrielles
venue_new
w=2684
0/3OUThigh
editorial/commentary

Review of two books on global financial governance and the IMF; the object is financial governance.

OUThigh
editorial/commentary

The work is a review of books about global financial governance and development finance.

OUThigh
editorial/commentary

Book review of global financial governance monographs; political economy commentary, not metaresearch.

Activity Level Maintenance at Midterm Follow-up Among Active Patients Undergoing Periacetabular Osteotomy
2019 · article · en · The American Journal of Sports Medicine
about_only
w=3321
0/3OUThigh
empirical

Clinical case series on activity levels after periacetabular osteotomy; the object is a surgical outcome.

OUThigh
empirical

The study evaluates activity outcomes after hip surgery rather than research itself.

OUThigh
empirical

Orthopedic outcomes after periacetabular osteotomy.

Preload Stress Echocardiography
2017 · letter · en · Circulation Cardiovascular Imaging
aff_core
w=5595
0/3OUThigh
editorial/commentary

Letter commenting on a clinical proof-of-concept echocardiography study; object is a clinical technique.

OUThigh
editorial/commentary

This letter comments on a clinical echocardiography study rather than studying research.

OUThigh
editorial/commentary

Clinical letter on preload stress echocardiography as a diagnostic technique, not metaresearch.

Chinese Canadian Fathers and Sons
2007 · article · fr · Canadian Children's Literature / Littérature canadienne pour la jeunesse
french
w=1554
0/3OUThigh
other

Piece in a children's literature journal on Chinese Canadian fathers and sons; the object is literary and cultural representation.

OUTlow
other

The title suggests a work about Chinese Canadian family or identity themes, but the missing abstract limits certainty.

OUTmedium
other

Children’s literature/identity piece on Chinese Canadian fathers and sons; cultural studies, not research systems.

At-line monitoring of salification process of the antiretroviral lamivudine-saccharinate salt using FT-MIR spectroscopy with multivariate curve resolution
2019 · article · en · Vibrational Spectroscopy
fund_new
w=1679
0/3OUThigh
empirical

Analytical chemistry study monitoring a salification process by FT-MIR spectroscopy; the object is a chemical process.

OUThigh
empirical

The study monitors a pharmaceutical salification process using spectroscopy.

OUTmedium
empirical

Pharmaceutical process analytical chemistry of lamivudine salt formation.

Coupled spin-charge-phonon fluctuation in the all-in/all-out antiferromagnet <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML"><mml:mrow><mml:msub><mml:mi>Cd</mml:mi><mml:mn>2</mml:mn></mml:msub><mml:msub><mml:mi>Os</mml:mi><mml:mn>2</mml:mn></mml:msub><mml:msub><mml:mi mathvariant="normal">O</mml:mi><mml:mn>7</mml:mn></mml:msub></mml:mrow></mml:math>
2019 · article · lv · Physical review. B./Physical review. B
fund_new
w=1679
0/3OUThigh
empirical

Condensed-matter physics study of spin-charge-phonon fluctuations in a pyrochlore antiferromagnet.

OUThigh
empirical

It investigates spin-charge-phonon fluctuations in a material, not research itself.

OUThigh
empirical

Condensed-matter physics of spin-charge-phonon fluctuations; domain physical science.

L’aura du futur antérieur: la postmodernité et la fin de l’histoire
2019 · article · fr · Surfaces
french
w=1554
0/3OUThigh
conceptual

Essay on postmodernity, cinema and the end of history; humanities theory.

OUThigh
conceptual

This analyzes postmodernity and filmic representations of history, not research itself.

OUThigh
conceptual

Film/cultural theory on postmodernity and history; not research practice.

Particulate Matter Exposure and Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder in Children: A Systematic Review of Epidemiological Studies
2019 · review · en · International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health
about_only
w=3321
0/3OUThigh
empirical

Systematic review of epidemiological studies on particulate matter exposure and ADHD; uses synthesis to answer an etiological question.

OUThigh
empirical

It conducts a systematic review to answer a clinical epidemiological question, not to study evidence synthesis.

OUThigh
empirical

Epidemiological systematic review of PM exposure and ADHD; clinical/health question.

Novel Alzheimer risk genes determine the microglia response to amyloid‐β but not to TAU pathology
2020 · article · en · EMBO Molecular Medicine
fund_new
w=1679
0/3OUThigh
empirical

Mouse-model transcriptomics of Alzheimer risk genes and microglial response; the object is disease biology.

OUThigh
empirical

The study investigates Alzheimer disease biology and genetic risk mechanisms, not research practice.

OUThigh
empirical

Biomedical genetics of Alzheimer risk genes and microglial response to pathology.

Rational design of hierarchical core-shell structured CoMoO4@CoS composites on reduced graphene oxide for supercapacitors with enhanced electrochemical performance
2020 · article · en · International Journal of Hydrogen Energy
fund_new
w=1679
0/3OUThigh
empirical

Materials chemistry paper on core-shell composites for supercapacitors.

OUTlow
other

The title identifies a materials engineering study, but the abstract is missing.

OUThigh
empirical

Materials science title on CoMoO4@CoS supercapacitor composites; domain energy materials.

A Computational Model of pH Dynamics within the Cleft of Conventional Neuronal Synapses
2020 · article · en · Biophysical Journal
aff_core
w=5595
0/3OUThigh
empirical

Computational model of synaptic cleft pH dynamics; a neuroscience question.

OUThigh
empirical

The work presents a computational model of synaptic pH dynamics.

OUTmedium
empirical

Computational model of synaptic cleft pH is neuroscience domain research; empty abstract but title is unambiguous.

Tout bouge autour de moi de Dany Laferrière au crible de l’éthique décoloniale de Fritta Caro
2020 · article · fr · ALTERNATIVE FRANCOPHONE
french
w=1554
0/3OUThigh
conceptual

French-language literary analysis of a Dany Laferriere essay through a decolonial ethical lens.

OUThigh
conceptual

It applies an ethical methodology to literary and colonial discourse rather than studying research.

OUThigh
conceptual

Literary/cultural reading of Laferrière via decolonial ethics; humanities analysis, not research studies.

Thrombotic microangiopathy in the course of catastrophic antiphospholipid syndrome successfully treated with eculizumab: case report and systematic review of the literature
2020 · review · en · Lupus
aff_core
w=5595
0/3OUThigh
empirical

Case report plus systematic review of a drug's efficacy in a rare syndrome; clinical question.

OUThigh
empirical

This systematic review evaluates a treatment for a clinical syndrome rather than evidence synthesis methodology.

OUThigh
empirical

Clinical review of eculizumab in catastrophic antiphospholipid syndrome, not metaresearch.

Avaliação do desenvolvimento motor infantil e sua associação com a vulnerabilidade social
2020 · article · pt · Fisioterapia e Pesquisa
about_only
w=3321
0/3OUThigh
empirical

Cross-sectional study of infant motor development and social vulnerability.

OUThigh
empirical

It studies infant motor development and social vulnerability, not research practice.

OUThigh
empirical

Cross-sectional study of infant motor development and social vulnerability in Brazil; clinical/public health.

Nonmotor-Related Quality of Life in Parkinson’s Patients with Subjective Memory Complaints: Comparison with PDQ-39
2020 · article · en · Parkinson s Disease
fund_new
w=1679
0/3OUThigh
empirical

Study of quality of life and memory complaints in Parkinson's patients; the call for validated tools is a clinical instrument note, not metaresearch.

OUThigh
empirical

This studies quality of life and memory complaints in Parkinson’s patients, not research itself.

OUThigh
empirical

Clinical study linking Parkinson's subjective memory complaints to quality of life; patient outcomes, not research practice.

Can green schools influence academic performance?
2020 · article · en · Critical Reviews in Environmental Science and Technology
aff_core
w=5595
0/3OUTmedium
empirical

Review synthesizing evidence on green school buildings; appraises the evidence base but answers a substantive domain question about student performance.

OUThigh
empirical

The review synthesizes evidence about green schools and academic performance rather than studying evidence synthesis.

OUThigh
empirical

Review linking green-school building factors to student academic outcomes; education environment, not research as object.

Integrated Design of Complex Mechanical Products Considering Modeling, Simulation and Optimization Aspects
2020 · dissertation · en · Open MIND
fund_new
w=1679
0/3OUThigh
empirical

Framework for integrated design, simulation and optimization of mechanical products; engineering design.

OUThigh
empirical

The dissertation develops an integrated engineering design system.

OUThigh
empirical

Integrated design framework for mechanical products; engineering design methods, not metaresearch.

Determination of earthquake epicentres based upon invariant quantities of GRACE strain gravity tensors
2020 · article · en · Scientific Reports
aff_core
w=5595
0/3OUThigh
empirical

Determination of earthquake epicentres from satellite gravity data; geophysics.

OUThigh
empirical

This study develops a geophysical method for locating earthquake epicentres, not a study of research methods.

OUThigh
empirical

Geophysical method to locate earthquake epicentres from GRACE gravity data; domain geoscience.

Simulation of Extreme Wind and Precipitation Patterns Associated with a Squall Line Passage in Southern Ontario on August 2, 2006
2008 · article · en · AGUFM
about_only
w=3321
0/3OUThigh
empirical

No abstract; meteorological simulation of a squall line; atmospheric science.

OUThigh
empirical

The work simulates meteorological conditions associated with a squall line.

OUTmedium
empirical

Meteorological simulation of a weather event; atmospheric science (no abstract).

Reply to Letter to the Editor
2014 · letter · en · Journal of Pediatric Surgery
aff_core
w=5595
0/3OUTlow
editorial/commentary

A clinical reply to a letter to the editor in pediatric surgery; correspondence on a clinical topic, not research practice.

T3high
editorial/commentary

It is a reply to a letter, a contextual scholarly communication item rather than an analytic study.

OUTlow
other

Bare reply letter with no abstract or topic text; cannot establish a metaresearch object.

Phase Transitions and Phase Miscibility of Mixed Particles of Ammonium Sulfate, Toluene-Derived Secondary Organic Material, and Water
2013 · article · en · The Journal of Physical Chemistry
aff_core
w=5595
0/3OUThigh
empirical

Phase behavior of atmospheric aerosol particles; physical chemistry.

OUThigh
empirical

The study investigates atmospheric particle phase behavior rather than research practice.

OUThigh
empirical

Atmospheric aerosol phase chemistry; physical science domain object.

Identité professionnelle et agressions dans les métiers spécialisés de la construction et du secteur manufacturier au Québec
2020 · article · fr · Relations industrielles
french
w=1554
0/3OUThigh
empirical

French-language study of professional identity and gender-based aggression among skilled trades workers in Quebec; workplace violence outside the research workforce.

OUThigh
empirical

It studies workplace identity and aggression in Québec industries, not research itself.

OUThigh
empirical

Occupational study of professional identity and workplace aggression in Quebec trades.

In memoriam: William Antony Swithin Sarjeant, 1935-2002
2002 · article · en · Blue Jay
venue_new
w=2684
0/3T3medium
other

Obituary of a scientist; T3 explicitly covers obituaries as contextual ecosystem material.

T3high
editorial/commentary

It is an obituary, a contextual genre rather than a study of research practice.

T3high
other

In memoriam/obituary; ecosystem contextual item, not analytic metaresearch.

Impact of COVID-19 on orthopaedic care: a call for nonoperative management
2020 · review · en · Therapeutic Advances in Musculoskeletal Disease
aff_core
w=5595
0/3OUTmedium
empirical

Systematic search summarizing COVID surgical guidance to inform care; uses a review to answer a clinical-management question.

OUThigh
empirical

This synthesizes clinical guidance on orthopaedic care during COVID-19, not evidence-synthesis methodology.

OUThigh
conceptual

Review of elective orthopaedic surgery guidance during COVID; clinical care pathways, not research practice.

The Status of Foreign Advanced Pasture Water Supply Technology
2020 · article · en · IOP Conference Series Earth and Environmental Science
about_only
w=3321
0/3OUThigh
empirical

Survey of pasture water-supply technologies; an agricultural engineering review of technology, not of research.

OUThigh
empirical

The object is pasture water-supply technology and its applications, not research.

OUThigh
other

Technical survey of pasture water-supply systems; literature is used for domain technology, not studied as research.

What the screen actually found

Three frontier models (Opus 4.8, GPT-5.6 high, Grok 4.5) screened the same 1,000 works from the REAL 4.3M frame, on the rubric's FULL eight-field payload, with randomized manifest-logged chunks and harness-written labels: every defect D1, D2, D11 and finding 16 identified, repaired. Design-weighted base rates span 1.89% to 3.54% (1.9x). But the sets are the finding, as finding 16 predicted: of the 51 works ANY model called metaresearch, only 19 (37%) were called metaresearch by ALL THREE, and 24 (47%) rest on a single model's opinion. THE FIELD'S BOUNDARY IS NOT A LINE THE MODELS SHARE; IT IS A REGION THEY EACH CUT DIFFERENTLY. GPT-5.6 also violated the locked output schema on 18 of 1,000 records, writing genre values into the tier field, which the manifest validator caught. The deliverable is not the base rate: it is the disagreement dossier, the 51 works that mark the empirical boundary of the field and against which the inclusion criteria must actually be written.

Computed 2026-07-12T19:52:14Z · all 22 findings · this dossier as JSON